Pin this Cake Batter Ice Cream Recipe for Later!

Why You’ll Fall in Love with This Easy Cake Batter Ice Cream Recipe:

This simple recipe for cake batter ice cream isn’t just a dessert; it’s an experience! Here’s why it stands out:

1. Significantly More Affordable than Coldstone & Other Specialty Shops!

   Creating your own cake batter ice cream at home offers incredible value. While specialty ice cream parlors charge a premium for unique flavors, you can achieve the same, if not better, quality for a fraction of the cost. You control the ingredients, the portion sizes, and the mix-ins, making it a budget-friendly way to enjoy a gourmet treat without compromising on flavor or fun.

2. Unlock More Flavor with Cake Batter Extract!

   The secret to that authentic birthday cake flavor isn’t just sprinkles; it’s the magical cake batter extract. This powerful little bottle can be found easily and affordably on Amazon, or in the baking aisle of many grocery stores. It’s not just for ice cream, either! This versatile extract is a game-changer for many desserts. I frequently use it to elevate my frosted birthday cake cookies, giving them an unmistakable celebratory flavor. But don’t stop there! Try adding a hint to:

   • Cookie dough (for a funfetti cookie experience!)
   • Frosting for cupcakes or cakes
   • Pancake or waffle batter for a festive breakfast
   • Milkshakes for an extra burst of flavor
   • Whipped cream for a unique topping

   Once you discover the magic of cake batter extract, you’ll find endless ways to infuse your baked goods and desserts with that beloved celebratory taste.

3. Customization at Your Fingertips:

   One of the biggest advantages of making your own cake batter ice cream is the freedom to customize. Want extra sprinkles? Go for it! Craving brownie chunks? Load ’em up! The possibilities are truly endless, allowing you to tailor each batch to your exact preferences or to fit any theme or occasion.

4. Quick & Easy Preparation:

   This recipe is designed for ease and speed. With minimal prep time and simple steps, you can have a batch of this delicious ice cream ready to enjoy in under 30 minutes, not including freezing time. It’s perfect for last-minute cravings or spontaneous celebrations.

Essential Ingredients for Your Homemade Cake Batter Ice Cream

You’ll be surprised at how few ingredients are needed to create this delightful dessert. Here’s a closer look at what you’ll need and some tips for selection:

• Vanilla Ice Cream (Key Base):

  The foundation of this cake batter ice cream is good quality vanilla ice cream. While any vanilla ice cream will work, I personally prefer a white vanilla bean ice cream (like Kroger’s “Artisan Vanilla Bean”) as it provides a clean, neutral base that allows the cake batter flavor and vibrant sprinkles to really shine. A premium, full-fat vanilla ice cream will also give you a richer, creamier final product. Make sure your ice cream is slightly softened before mixing – this makes it much easier to incorporate the extract and mix-ins without overworking it.

• Cake Batter Extract (The Secret Ingredient):

  This is where the magic happens! Cake batter extract is crucial for achieving that authentic, nostalgic flavor of raw cake batter. As mentioned, you can easily find this on Amazon (it’s surprisingly affordable!) or in the baking section of larger grocery stores. McCormick brand is a popular and reliable choice. Don’t be tempted to skip this or substitute with vanilla extract alone; the cake batter extract has a unique, buttery, and slightly almond-like flavor that is irreplaceable for this recipe.

• Mix-ins (Optional, but Highly Recommended for Fun!):

  This is where your creativity can truly flourish! Mix-ins add texture, color, and additional layers of flavor to your cake batter ice cream. The options are limitless, but here are some fantastic ideas:

  • Rainbow Sprinkles: Essential for that funfetti look! Jimmie sprinkles (the long, cylindrical ones) tend to hold their shape better than nonpareils (tiny balls) which can sometimes bleed color.
  • Brownie Bites: Crumbled or cut into small pieces, brownies add a delicious fudgy contrast.
  • Hot Fudge or Caramel Swirl: Swirl in these sauces during the final mixing step for ribbons of decadent flavor.
  • Crushed Cookies: Oreos, shortbread, or even sugar cookies can add a delightful crunch.
  • Cake Pieces: If you have leftover cake, crumble it in for an extra cakey texture.
  • Chocolate Chips: Mini chocolate chips work wonderfully.
  • Edible Cookie Dough Chunks: A classic ice cream add-in that pairs perfectly with cake batter flavor.
  • Candies: M&Ms, chopped candy bars, or gummy bears (add these just before serving to prevent them from freezing too hard).
  • Toasted Nuts: For a nutty crunch.

  Choose one or several to create your ultimate cake batter ice cream masterpiece!

Method 1: Using a Stand Mixer (Recommended for Best Texture)

1. Prepare Your Bowl: For optimal creaminess and to prevent the ice cream from melting too quickly, place a metal KitchenAid mixing bowl (or any large, freezer-safe metal bowl) into the freezer for 20-30 minutes. This pre-chilling step helps maintain the ice cream’s consistency during mixing.
2. Soften Ice Cream Slightly: Take your vanilla ice cream out of the freezer about 10-15 minutes before you plan to mix, allowing it to soften just enough so it’s scoopable but not completely melted.
3. Combine Ingredients: Transfer the slightly softened ice cream to your chilled mixing bowl. Add the cake batter extract.
4. Mix Until Combined: Attach the paddle attachment to your stand mixer. Begin mixing on low speed, gradually increasing to medium, until the extract is fully incorporated into the ice cream. The mixture should be smooth and creamy, but still firm. Avoid overmixing, as this can introduce too much air or melt the ice cream excessively.
5. Stir in Mix-ins: Once combined, gently fold in your desired mix-ins (like sprinkles, brownie bits, or cookie chunks) using a sturdy spatula. Stir just enough to evenly distribute them throughout the ice cream.
6. Serve or Freeze: Enjoy immediately for a softer, ‘soft-serve’ consistency, or transfer to an airtight container and freeze for at least 2-3 hours (or overnight) for a firmer, scoopable ice cream.

Method 2: Using a Blender (Quick & Easy)

1. Blend Ice Cream and Extract: Place your softened vanilla ice cream and cake batter extract into a powerful blender.
2. Achieve Smooth Consistency: Blend on low to medium speed until smooth and fully combined. Depending on your blender’s power and the ice cream’s softness, you might need to add a tablespoon or two of milk (dairy or non-dairy) to help it blend smoothly. Add just enough to facilitate blending, being careful not to make the mixture too liquidy.
3. Fold in Mix-ins: Once blended, transfer the mixture to a bowl and gently stir in your chosen mix-ins with a spoon or spatula.
4. Freeze: Transfer the ice cream to an airtight container and freeze for at least 3-4 hours, or until firm enough to scoop.

Expert Tips & Creative Variations for Your Cake Batter Ice Cream

Take your homemade cake batter ice cream to the next level with these expert tips and fun variations:

• Endless Mix-in Possibilities:

  While sprinkles are a must, don’t limit yourself! Experiment with different types of candy, chopped cookies, or even pieces of actual cake (like leftover vanilla or Funfetti cake). For an extra decadent touch, try mini marshmallows, white chocolate chips, or a swirl of peanut butter. The key is to add mix-ins during the final mixing step to ensure they’re evenly distributed without getting crushed.

• Transform it into an Ice Cream Cake:

  This cake batter ice cream is the perfect base for an easy, no-bake ice cream cake! Simply spread a layer of the freshly mixed ice cream over a pan of brownies, a pre-baked cake layer, or even a crushed cookie crust. Freeze until firm, then top with whipped cream, more sprinkles, and perhaps a drizzle of hot fudge. Slice and serve for an impressive, festive dessert.

• Achieve the Perfect Softness:

  For the best mixing results, ensure your vanilla ice cream is slightly softened but not melted. If it’s too hard, it will be difficult to mix evenly. If it’s too soft, the final texture might be icier once refrozen. The ideal consistency is when it’s easily scoopable with a spoon.

• Storage for Optimal Freshness:

  To prevent ice crystals from forming and keep your cake batter ice cream smooth and creamy, store it in an airtight container in the coldest part of your freezer. For extra protection, press a piece of plastic wrap directly onto the surface of the ice cream before sealing the container. This limits air exposure and maintains quality.

• Make it a Milkshake:

  If you prefer a drinkable treat, blend a scoop or two of your cake batter ice cream with a splash of milk for an instant, delicious milkshake. You can add extra cake batter extract or a drop of food coloring for more fun.

• Dietary Considerations:

  For those with dietary restrictions, consider using a dairy-free vanilla ice cream alternative. Most cake batter extracts are vegan-friendly, but always check the label. You can still achieve that wonderful cake batter flavor!

• Party Perfection:

  This cake batter ice cream is an absolute crowd-pleaser for birthday parties, summer gatherings, or any celebration. You can even set up an ice cream bar with various mix-ins and toppings, letting guests customize their own scoops.

Click Here to Pin this Recipe for Later!