Click Here to Pin this Recipe for Later!

Why You’ll Adore These Effortless Rudolph Cookies

These Rudolph sugar cookies aren’t just cute; they’re designed for maximum fun and minimal stress, making them a holiday baking favorite for families. Here’s why you’ll fall in love with them this Christmas season:

1. No Special Decorating Supplies Needed: Say goodbye to expensive, single-use Christmas cookie cutters or elaborate piping bags. These adorable reindeer cookies can be decorated using just one color of frosting – typically a lovely brown – and readily available M&M candies. It’s decorating made simple, allowing anyone to achieve professional-looking results without the fuss.
2. Quick to Make: Unlike many intricate sugar cookie designs that demand hours of precise work, these Rudolph treats can be whipped up and decorated in under an hour (excluding baking and cooling time). If you’re really short on time or want to focus purely on the decorating fun, you can even use pre-made sugar cookie dough from your local grocery store, like Pillsbury, to speed up the process even further. This makes them perfect for spontaneous baking sessions or busy holiday schedules.
3. Fun Activity for Kids: This recipe is a fantastic way to involve children in holiday baking. There’s no need for intricate piping skills or steady hands; kids can simply spread on the frosting and then proudly top their cookies with M&M’s to create the iconic reindeer faces and mini pretzels for antlers. It’s a creative, hands-on activity that fosters imagination and results in delicious, edible art!
4. Includes Free Printable Guide: To make the decorating process even smoother, especially for younger decorators, I’ve included a free printable cookie instruction sheet. This guide features clear, step-by-step illustrations, helping kids (and adults!) visualize exactly how to assemble each charming Rudolph face. It’s like having a helpful elf guiding you through every step!
5. Perfect for Parties & Gifts: These cheerful Rudolph cookies are ideal for holiday parties, school events, or as thoughtful homemade gifts. Their charming appearance and delightful taste are sure to be a hit with everyone, adding a personalized touch to any festive celebration.

Psst! Looking for more cute and easy Christmas cookies to make with M&M’s? Check out my collection of 5 EASY Christmas Cookies for Kids for additional inspiration and fun designs!

Essential Supplies for Your Reindeer Sugar Cookie Adventure

Gathering your ingredients and tools for these simple DIY reindeer cookies couldn’t be easier. You won’t need an elaborate setup, just a few key items to get started on your delicious Christmas project with pretzels and M&M’s!

• Cut-out Sugar Cookie Dough (my favorite recipe is included below, or use store-bought for convenience). This forms the perfect sturdy base for your reindeer faces.
• White Buttercream Frosting (the recipe and specific color formulas for brown are provided in the recipe card). Buttercream provides a stable, delicious base for your M&M decorations without bleeding colors.
• M&M Candies: You’ll primarily need brown M&M’s for the eyes and a handful of red M&M’s for Rudolph’s iconic nose. Green or other colors can also be used for extra festive touches if you desire!
• Mini Pretzels: These are essential for creating the charming antlers atop each Rudolph cookie. The twisted shape perfectly mimics reindeer antlers.
• Circle Cookie Cutter or Glass Cup: An approximately 2.5″ to 3″ diameter circle cutter is ideal. Don’t have one? A glass cup of similar size works just as well – no special equipment needed!
• Bonus: Don’t forget the Free Printable Instruction Guide for Kids! This visual aid is a game-changer for little hands learning to decorate.
• Basic Kitchen Tools: You’ll also need standard baking essentials such as mixing bowls, measuring cups and spoons, a rolling pin, a spatula or butter knife for spreading frosting, and baking sheets lined with parchment paper.

Important Tip: I highly recommend using a thicker, stable frosting like buttercream for these cookies. Avoid “wet” icing types such as royal icing or glaze icing. The moisture in these icings can cause the vibrant colors of the M&M’s to bleed, affecting the neatness of your Rudolph faces.

Step 1: Prepare and Bake Your Circle Cookies

Begin by preparing your chosen sugar cookie dough. If using my recommended recipe (found in the recipe card below), ensure your dough is chilled as specified for best results. Once ready, roll out the dough evenly to a thickness of approximately ⅜” to ½”. Using your circle cookie cutter (or a glass cup), cut out uniform circles. Carefully transfer these circles to a baking sheet lined with parchment paper.

Bake the cookies according to your recipe’s instructions until the edges are lightly golden and the centers are just set. Avoid over-baking to keep them soft and chewy. Once baked, let them cool completely on a wire rack before you even think about decorating. A fully cooled cookie is crucial for proper frosting adhesion and to prevent melting.

Step 2: Color and Frost Your Cookies

Now for the fun part: adding color! Prepare your buttercream frosting. To achieve the perfect Rudolph brown, use the specific color formula provided in the recipe card: add 4 drops of brown Wilton gel food coloring and 2 drops of Wilton yellow gel food coloring to 2 cups of white frosting. Gel food coloring is recommended as it provides vibrant color without thinning the frosting.

Once your frosting is beautifully brown, use a butter knife or a small offset spatula to spread a generous, even layer over the top of each cooled cookie. For those who prefer a tidier look or slightly cleaner edges, a piping bag with a round tip can be used, but it’s absolutely not necessary for these rustic, charming cookies. The goal is even coverage, so don’t stress about perfection!

Step 3: Bring Rudolph to Life with Decorations!

This is where the magic happens and your Rudolph cookies get their character! While the frosting is still soft and “wet” – before it has a chance to set – carefully press your candies and pretzels into place. This ensures they adhere securely to the cookie.

• For the Eyes: Place two brown M&M’s near the top center of each cookie to create Rudolph’s expressive eyes.
• For Rudolph’s Nose: Position one bright red M&M just below the eyes for that famous glowing red nose.
• For the Mouth (Optional): For an extra touch of charm, you can add a small smile. Carefully press half of a brown M&M just below the nose to form the mouth.
• For the Antlers: Finish off your reindeer by pressing two mini pretzels onto the top edge of the cookie, just above the eyes, to form the antlers. You might need to gently push them into the frosting to ensure they stand upright.

What can I use instead of M&M’s for the eyes and nose?

While M&M’s offer vibrant colors and a classic look, you have several alternatives. For the eyes, you can use chocolate chips (mini or regular, depending on desired size) or small edible eyeball sprinkles for a cartoonish effect. If you’re feeling a bit more ambitious and want to avoid candies, you could dye a small amount of frosting black for eyes and red for the nose, then pipe on the details using a very small round tip or a toothpick. Keep in mind this method can be a bit messier and requires a steadier hand, but it offers full control over the expression!

How exactly do I make brown frosting?

Creating the perfect brown for Rudolph is simple! Start with your batch of white buttercream frosting. For every 1 cup of white frosting, add 2 drops of brown gel food coloring and 1 drop of yellow gel food coloring. Mix thoroughly. If the color isn’t quite as deep or rich as you’d like, add gel food coloring one drop at a time, mixing after each addition, until you achieve your desired shade. Gel food colors are preferred because they provide intense color without adding excess liquid that could thin out your frosting.

Can I freeze these Rudolph cookies for later enjoyment?

Absolutely! These frosted reindeer cookies are freezer-friendly. You can freeze them for up to 1 month in an airtight container. To prevent them from sticking together or smudging the decorations, I recommend flash-freezing them first. Place the decorated cookies in a single layer on a baking sheet and freeze for about 30 minutes to an hour until the frosting is firm. Once frozen, you can stack them in an airtight container, placing a piece of parchment paper or wax paper between each layer. Thaw them at room temperature before serving.

Can I make these Rudolph cookies ahead of time?

Yes, making these cookies ahead of time is a fantastic idea, especially during the busy holiday season! You have a couple of options:

1. Freeze Unfrosted Cookies: Bake the sugar cookies as instructed and let them cool completely. Then, freeze the unfrosted cookies in an airtight container for up to 2-3 months. When you’re ready to decorate, simply let them thaw to room temperature, then proceed with frosting and decorating. This is a great option if you plan to host a cookie decorating party!

2. Freeze Frosted Cookies: As mentioned above, you can also freeze the fully decorated cookies for up to a month.

Preparing them in advance helps to spread out your holiday baking tasks and ensures you have fresh-tasting treats ready when you need them.

What’s the best cookie base for these Rudolph cookies?

For the best results, a sturdy yet soft cut-out sugar cookie is ideal. My favorite recipe (included in the recipe card) holds its shape beautifully while baking, providing a smooth canvas for frosting and decorations. You want a cookie that isn’t too crumbly or too soft, ensuring it can support the M&M’s and pretzels without breaking. Using a dough that spreads minimally is also a key factor in keeping those perfect circle shapes.

My pretzel antlers keep breaking or falling off. Any tips?

Pretzels can be delicate! To minimize breakage, handle them gently. When attaching them, ensure your frosting is still soft enough for the pretzels to embed slightly and adhere well. If the frosting has started to set, it might be too firm. You can also try breaking larger pretzels into antler-like shapes beforehand, giving you more control and potentially sturdier pieces. If they still feel loose, a tiny dot of fresh frosting applied to the back of the pretzel where it meets the cookie can act as extra “glue” to secure it.

Explore More Unique Christmas Cookie Ideas Using M&M’s!

The versatility of M&M’s and a simple round cookie cutter opens up a world of creative possibilities for your holiday baking! If you loved making these Rudolph cookies, you’re in for a treat with more ideas:

• For a collection of diverse designs that are just as easy, be sure to check out my comprehensive guide to 5 EASY Christmas Cookies for Kids! These recipes utilize the same round cookie base and simple decorating techniques, making them perfect for little helpers.
• Want to try a different flavor profile? You can easily turn these into delicious peanut butter reindeer cookies! Simply use my recipe for thick & soft peanut butter cookies as your base. Instead of frosting, you can use a small dab of melted chocolate to “glue” the M&M’s (eyes and nose) and pretzels (antlers) onto the peanut butter cookies. The rich peanut butter flavor pairs wonderfully with chocolate!
• Circle Gingerbread Man Cookies: With a round cookie, you can pipe on simple gingerbread man features with white frosting and use mini M&M’s for buttons or eyes. See my Circle Gingerbread Man Sugar Cookies for inspiration!
• Santa Face Sugar Cookies: Another adorable option using a round base! Frost the top half with white frosting for Santa’s beard and rim, and the bottom half with red for his hat. Use two mini brown M&M’s for eyes and a small red M&M for his nose. My Santa Face Sugar Cookies provide a fantastic guide.
• Snowman Cookies: Frost a round cookie with white frosting, then use M&M’s for buttons, a cut orange M&M for a carrot nose, and piped black frosting for eyes and a smile. So simple and effective!