Why You’ll Love This Christmas Cookie Frosting Recipe:

There are countless reasons why this particular sugar cookie buttercream stands out from the rest. It’s designed to be both incredibly easy to make and exceptionally delicious, ensuring your holiday cookie decorating is a joyful and successful endeavor. Here’s what makes this recipe a true winner:

1. Uses 5 Simple, Accessible Ingredients: You don’t need a pantry full of exotic items for this recipe! It requires just a handful of basic ingredients you likely already have: powdered sugar, unsalted butter, vanilla extract, almond extract (optional), and a tiny pinch of salt. These common staples come together to create an extraordinary frosting that’s both economical and convenient.
2. Perfect Consistency For Both Spreading & Piping: Achieving the right frosting consistency is key for beautiful cookie decoration. This buttercream is specifically formulated to be versatile, offering a smooth, creamy texture that’s thick enough to hold its shape when piped, yet soft enough to spread effortlessly with a butter knife or offset spatula. This makes it ideal for a wide range of decorating styles, from simple floods to more intricate designs.
3. It Slightly Hardens for Easy Stacking: Unlike many soft buttercreams, this recipe develops a light crust once dry. This crucial feature means you can carefully stack your decorated Christmas cookies without fear of smudging or ruining your hard work. It’s a lifesaver for transporting cookies to holiday parties or gifting them to loved ones. While it doesn’t harden to the rock-solid finish of royal icing, it provides enough stability for practical handling.
4. Tastes Absolutely Amazing – Like a Bakery Treat: Flavor is paramount, and this homemade sugar cookie frosting truly delivers! It’s perfectly balanced with the warm, comforting notes of vanilla extract and a subtle, delightful hint of almond extract (which is optional but highly recommended for an extra special touch). This rich, creamy, and flavorful combination makes it the ideal companion for your favorite sugar cookie recipe, transforming simple cut-out cookies into a gourmet experience that tastes just like a $5 bakery sugar cookie.

Looking for the perfect gift for a baker in your life? Check out our recommendations for the Best Rolling Pin for Sugar Cookies!

Understanding Ratios: This full buttercream frosting recipe yields approximately 2 cups of frosting, which is typically enough to generously frost about 24 average-sized (e.g., 2.5″ circle) cut-out sugar cookies, depending on their design and thickness of frosting. Since many bakers like to dye their frosting in multiple shades for various designs, I’ve created these color formulas per 1 cup of frosting. If you wish to dye the entire batch of frosting one solid color, simply double the suggested amounts for each color.

My Preferred Food Coloring: For consistent, vibrant, and professional-looking colors, I highly recommend the Wilton Color Right Set. This gel-based coloring system offers highly concentrated colors, meaning you need less product to achieve intense shades, which helps maintain the frosting’s perfect consistency. It’s a fantastic investment if you plan to create a wide spectrum of colors.

Don’t Underestimate White Frosting: While we’re focusing on vibrant colors, don’t feel obligated to dye every batch! Pure white frosting is incredibly versatile and creates beautiful, classic Christmas designs. It’s perfect for creating elegant candy canes, sparkling snowflakes, cheerful snowmen, fluffy parts of mittens, or even as a base for colorful sprinkles and candies. Sometimes, less is more, and white provides a clean canvas for other festive embellishments!

How to Make Classic Christmas Red Frosting

Achieving a true, deep Christmas red can be challenging. A common problem is having to add so much food coloring that the frosting develops an unpleasant chemical taste – yuck! This formula helps you get a rich, vibrant red without the off-flavor.

• Per 1 cup frosting: Combine 4 drops of Wilton Crimson with 2 drops of Wilton Red. The crimson base gives it depth, while the red brightens it to that iconic holiday shade.
• Classic red frosting is perfect for: Festive stockings, jolly Santa hats and suits, classic candy cane stripes, cozy mittens, ornaments, and of course, Rudolph’s bright red nose!

---

How to Make Dazzling Christmas Emerald Green Frosting

This deep, jewel-toned green is rich and sophisticated, perfect for creating luxurious holiday designs that truly pop. It evokes the feeling of a lush, evergreen forest.

• Per 1 cup of frosting: Mix 3 drops of Wilton Blue with 2 drops of Wilton Yellow. The blue provides depth, while the yellow adds warmth, creating a vibrant emerald.
• Emerald green frosting is perfect for: Majestic Christmas trees, elegant wreaths, intricate ornaments, and cheerful Christmas lights.

Tip: For even more dark green icing variations and formulas, check out my detailed guide on How To Make Dark Green Icing (5 Shades!).

How to Make Zesty Lime Green Frosting

This bright, cheerful lime green adds a fun, modern twist to your traditional Christmas cookie palette. It’s lively and playful!

• Per 1 cup frosting: Use 1 drop of Wilton Yellow and just a toothpick swipe of Wilton Blue. To do a toothpick swipe, dip the tip of a clean toothpick about ½” into the blue food coloring, then transfer that small amount to your frosting and mix thoroughly.
• Lime green frosting is perfect for: Cheerful Christmas trees, playful wreaths, vibrant ornaments, and bright Christmas lights.

How to Make Delicate Mint Green Frosting

This soft, pastel mint green offers a subtle, enchanting alternative to bolder greens. It’s perfect for adding a touch of elegance or a cool, frosty feel to your designs.

• Per 1 cup frosting: Use 1 toothpick swipe of Wilton Yellow and 1 toothpick swipe of Wilton Blue. Remember the toothpick swipe technique: dip the tip about ½” into the coloring, then transfer to the frosting. Mix well to achieve a soft, balanced mint.
• Mint green frosting is perfect for: Shimmering Christmas lights, elegant snowflakes, frosty trees, and twinkling stars.

How to Make Warm Gingerbread Frosting

This rich brown frosting perfectly captures the cozy, spiced essence of gingerbread. It’s a wonderful color for creating characters and rustic holiday scenes.

• Per 1 cup frosting: Use 2 drops of Wilton Brown (from the Color Right Set) and 1 drop of Wilton Yellow. The yellow adds a warm undertone, preventing the brown from looking too stark.
• Brown frosting is perfect for: Adorable gingerbread men and women, sturdy tree trunks for your Christmas trees, and cute reindeer.

This particular sugar cookie frosting recipe is made primarily with butter and powdered sugar, and importantly, it contains no milk. This means it is stable enough to be left at room temperature for up to 2-3 days, making it convenient for decorating sessions. However, if you’re not planning to frost your cookies right away, or if you have leftovers, it’s best to place the frosting in an airtight container and store it in the refrigerator. When it’s time to use it, simply let it sit out at room temperature for an hour or two to soften. Then, re-beat it with an electric mixer for a few minutes until it’s light, fluffy, and perfectly spreadable again. If you live in a particularly hot or humid climate where your kitchen tends to be warm, storing the frosting in the refrigerator is always the safest bet to prevent it from becoming too soft.

Yes, absolutely! You can freeze your beautifully frosted sugar cookies to enjoy them later. For best results, place the frosted cookies in a single layer on a baking sheet and freeze until solid (this prevents them from sticking together). Once solid, transfer them to an airtight container, separating layers with parchment paper. They can be frozen for up to 2 months. I don’t recommend freezing them for much longer than that, as the frosting can eventually crystalize, and the cookies might start to lose their fresh flavor and texture. To thaw, simply allow the sugar cookies to sit out on the counter at room temperature for 1-2 hours before serving. This gentle thawing process helps preserve their taste and appearance.

You certainly can! Freezing this sugar cookie frosting is a great way to prep ahead for holiday baking or to save any leftover buttercream. To freeze, place the frosting in an airtight container. For an extra layer of protection against freezer burn, press a piece of plastic wrap directly onto the surface of the frosting before sealing the container. It can be frozen for up to 2 months. When you’re ready to use it, remove it from the freezer and let it thaw completely to room temperature. Once thawed, transfer it to a mixing bowl and re-beat it with an electric mixer on medium-high speed for several minutes until it becomes light, fluffy, and smooth again. This re-whipping step is crucial to restore its perfect consistency for decorating.

Yes, you absolutely can omit the almond extract if you prefer! The almond extract in this sugar cookie frosting recipe is included to enhance the overall vanilla flavor and add a subtle, bakery-like depth that many adore. However, it is entirely optional. If you or your guests have nut allergies, or if you simply prefer a pure vanilla sugar cookie flavor, feel free to leave out the almond extract. In that case, you might consider adding an extra half-teaspoon to a full teaspoon of vanilla extract to taste, ensuring your frosting still has a rich, delightful aroma and flavor.

Definitely! This buttercream frosting recipe is wonderfully adaptable, making it a fantastic base for experimenting with different flavors beyond vanilla and almond. Feel free to get creative and try adding a few drops (adjust to taste) of other extracts. Consider a festive peppermint extract for a cool, refreshing twist, or lemon flavoring for a bright and zesty kick. Strawberry flavoring can add a fruity note, while coconut extract offers a subtle yet unique tropical aroma – I personally LOVE adding a few drops of coconut extract; I know it sounds a little unconventional, but it gives the frosting such a delicate and unexpected deliciousness! Always add extracts slowly and taste as you go, as their intensity can vary.