Homemade Peanut Butter with Olive Oil & Honey: Your Guide to a Creamy, Delicious DIY Spread
For many, peanut butter isn’t just a pantry staple; it’s a culinary obsession, a comfort food, and an indispensable part of daily life. I count myself firmly in this camp. My love for peanut butter runs deep, a devotion that was put to the ultimate test during my time living in Italy. While Italy is a paradise for many things, the readily available, affordable peanut butter we take for granted in many parts of the world is, surprisingly, not one of them. This harsh reality hit hard, turning what should have been an effortless craving into a full-blown quest.
The Great Italian Peanut Butter Scavenger Hunt
Last year, during my four months in Italy, the absence of peanut butter became a daily challenge. Supermarket aisles, usually brimming with tempting delights, offered only a sparse selection, if any. When a rare jar did appear, it was typically a small, imported novelty item, boasting an exorbitant price tag – often around $8 for a tiny container! This forced me into unconventional ways to satisfy my peanut cravings. My diet skewed heavily towards peanut M&Ms, a delicious but far from nutritious substitute. Daily trips for peanut butter gelato became a ritual, a sweet, albeit temporary, fix for my yearning for that rich, nutty flavor. We spent countless hours mapping out the few, elusive supermarkets that miraculously stocked some form of peanut butter, often finding only two out of a hundred stores carried it.
Those months were certainly an adventure, a whirlwind of cultural immersion and culinary compromise. While I wouldn’t call them the healthiest period of my life, they were undeniably memorable. When in Rome, right? Or, in my case, when in Italy, find creative ways to get your peanut butter fix!
My First Attempt: A Manual Mishap and a Crucial Realization
About two months into my Italian semester, after splurging on tiny, overpriced jars of peanut butter, I decided enough was enough. It was time to take matters into my own hands. I bought some shelled peanuts from the local grocery store, brimming with confidence and determination to craft my own homemade peanut butter. What I didn’t fully consider was the essential role of proper equipment. Upon returning home, my enthusiasm quickly deflated as I realized a critical appliance was missing: a food processor.
Undeterred, but slightly desperate, I sat on my bed with a bowl, a pan, and a glass cup. My method involved meticulously unshelling the peanuts and then attempting to crush them with the bottom of the glass. The result, as you might imagine, was far from the creamy, spreadable delight I envisioned. Instead, I ended up with what could only be described as a chunky, oily peanut salad, perhaps more suited for a very adventurous dressing than a sandwich spread. This comical failure served as a crucial lesson: a food processor isn’t just helpful for making peanut butter; it’s absolutely vital.
A Triumphant Return and a Successful Second Try
Now, safely back on home soil, with access to modern kitchen appliances, I was ready to redeem myself. My return home last week always signals one thing: an exciting spree of baking and, often, kitchen-related experiments. This time, I enlisted my siblings for assistance, a task made surprisingly easy thanks to the ultimate incentive: a Dairy Queen Blizzard. Seriously, if you ever need a little extra motivation for someone to run an errand, a Blizzard is a guaranteed game-changer. It’s an unspoken rule of sibling cooperation!
With cash in hand and the promise of a frosty treat, my siblings dutifully returned with the “gold”—a fresh bag of peanuts. I immediately got to work. This time, armed with my mom’s powerful blender (a true kitchen beast!), the process was remarkably smooth. I poured the peanuts in, and within minutes, they transformed from whole nuts into a coarse meal, then a sticky paste, and finally, a smooth, luscious butter. To enhance the flavor and texture, I added a generous drizzle of golden honey for natural sweetness and a touch of extra virgin olive oil, which contributes to the spread’s creaminess and a subtle, sophisticated depth of flavor. The best part? It was ready in mere minutes, a deliciously semi-chunky version of my favorite treat, with the absolute certainty of knowing exactly what ingredients went into it.
Even better, it earned the coveted sibling approval. They devoured it without question, testament to its deliciousness. I decided to keep the olive oil a secret; sometimes, it’s just better that way. The natural sweetness of the honey beautifully complements the robust peanut flavor, creating a harmonious blend that’s simply irresistible.
Why Homemade Peanut Butter is a Game Changer
While I typically lean towards creamy peanut butter, this homemade version, with its delightful semi-chunky texture, has completely won me over. The pure, unadulterated peanut flavor shines through, subtly balanced by the honey, and surprisingly, the olive oil doesn’t overpower it at all. Instead, it contributes to a wonderfully rich mouthfeel and a nuanced taste profile that commercial peanut butter often lacks. Knowing that it’s made with simple, wholesome ingredients provides an extra layer of satisfaction that store-bought varieties can’t match.
Making your own peanut butter offers numerous benefits:
- Control over Ingredients: Say goodbye to unnecessary sugars, hydrogenated oils, and artificial preservatives. You choose what goes in, ensuring a healthier and more natural spread.
- Customizable Texture: Whether you prefer super creamy or extra chunky, you can blend to your desired consistency.
- Adjustable Flavor: Sweeten it with honey, maple syrup, or dates, or add a pinch of salt for a savory kick. You can even experiment with spices like cinnamon or a dash of vanilla extract.
- Freshness: Nothing beats the taste of freshly made peanut butter. The aroma and flavor are unparalleled.
- Cost-Effective: Buying raw or roasted peanuts in bulk can often be more economical than purchasing specialty or organic peanut butter from the store.
Spread it on crackers, toast, apple slices, or add a dollop to your morning oatmeal or smoothie. Let me tell you, this olive oil and honey infused homemade peanut butter is a match made in heaven for any snack or breakfast. It’s incredibly versatile and satisfying.
Olive Oil & Honey Homemade Peanut Butter
Print
Rate
Ingredients
- 16 oz. dry-roasted peanuts unshelled
- 4 tablespoons extra virgin olive oil
- 4 teaspoons honey
Before you begin! If you make this, will you do me a huge favor and leave a review and rating letting me know how you liked this recipe? This helps my small business thrive so I can continue providing free recipes and high-quality content for you.
Instructions
-
In a food processor, crush the dry-roasted peanuts (16 ounces) for 30 seconds on high speed. You’ll see them transform from whole nuts to a coarse meal.
-
Add in extra virgin olive oil (4 tablespoons) and honey (4 tablespoons). Continue to blend until the peanut butter reaches your desired creaminess, usually another 2-3 minutes. It will go from a thick paste to a smoother, spreadable consistency.
-
If needed, pause the food processor and scrape down the sides of the bowl halfway through mixing to ensure all ingredients are thoroughly incorporated. This helps achieve an even texture.
-
Transfer your fresh homemade peanut butter to an air-tight container. Store it in the refrigerator for up to one month to maintain its freshness and flavor.
Last Step! Please leave a review and rating letting me know how you liked this recipe! Your feedback helps my small business thrive so I can continue providing free recipes and high-quality content for you.
Nutrition Information (per serving, estimated)
Have you ever attempted to make homemade peanut butter? Share your experiences and tips in the comments below!
There’s immense satisfaction in crafting something delicious from scratch, especially when it’s a beloved staple like peanut butter. This journey from an Italian peanut butter drought to a successful homemade spread has been a delightful culinary adventure. I encourage you to try this simple recipe and experience the joy of making your own healthy, flavorful peanut butter right in your kitchen!